Roof Shingle Damage: 7 Most Common Issues + Fixes [2025 Guide]

Did you know 90% of shingle roof failures start with these 7 problems?

Roof shingle damage isn’t always obvious until it causes roof leaks, mold, or sky-high repair costs. Whether it’s curling edges from summer heat, granules clogging your gutters, or wind damage roof shingles, small issues quickly escalate.

This isn’t just about aesthetics. Cracked or missing shingles expose your home to water damage, pest infestation, and even structural rot. 

The good news? Most types of shingle roof problems can be repaired with simple fixes if caught early. But waiting too long could cost you thousands.

This guide explores everything from early signs of roof shingle damage, repair methods, cost estimates, and expert-backed prevention tips to help extend your roof’s life.

“Roof shingle damage is the top reason for premature roof failure,” say Corey and Corey, the roofers. “Yet 80% of homeowners miss the early warning signs.”

This guide is part of our ‘15 Common Roofing Problems’ series—your go-to resource for spotting and fixing roof issues before they become expensive.

Let’s start with the first and most overlooked issue: curling shingles…

7 Most common shingle roof issues & how to fix each

1. Curling Shingles: Causes & Fixes

What It Looks Like

Shingle edges curl upward (cupping) or downward (clawing), creating an uneven roof surface.

Main Causes

• Poor attic ventilation (trapped heat & moisture)
• Aging shingles (drying out & losing flexibility)
• Improper installation (overdriven nails, low-quality adhesive)
• Extreme weather (repeated heat/cold cycles)

Risks of Ignoring It

• Leaks (water seeps under lifted edges)
• Granule loss (exposes asphalt to UV damage)
• Higher replacement costs (if >30% of roof is affected)

How to Fix Roof Shingle Damage

• Minor curling: Seal edges with roofing cement (temporary fix).
• Severe curling: Replace damaged shingles. If widespread, consider asphalt roof replacement.
• Prevention: Improve attic ventilation. For durability, upgrade to architectural shingle installation.

Cost:

• Spot repair: $150–$400
• Full replacement: $5,000–$12,000

Note: The shingle roof repair prices listed here are approximate—actual costs may vary depending on the contractor and the complexity of the issue.

Key Differences at a Glance

Pro Tip: Use binoculars to inspect for curling from the ground. If you see more than 10 affected shingles per 100 sq ft, consult a Cape Cod roofer for the best roofing services in Cape Cod. Call 508-775-8240 for a free inspection.

2. Missing Shingles (Most Common After Storms)

What It Looks Like

Bare spots where shingles have blown off or fallen off.

Immediate Risks

• 1 missing shingle = 1 sq ft of exposed decking
• Can lead to leaks within 2 rainstorms

Step-by-Step Replacement

Materials Needed:

• Replacement shingles (save extras from original install)
• Roofing nails (1¼ galvanized)
• Pry bar & roofing cement

Process:

1. Slide the pry bar under the intact shingles above the gap.
2. Remove remaining nail fragments
3. Slide the new shingle into place, aligning with neighbors
4. Nail 1″ above cutout slots (4 nails per shingle)
5. Seal edges with roofing cement

When to Call a Roofing Contractor:

• If >3 shingles are missing
• When the roof decking feels soft (indicates rot)

Emergency Measures While Waiting for Roofing Contractor:

1. Cover the area with:
   • Peel-and-stick ice/water shield (best option)
   • Heavy-duty tarp secured with 2x4s (temporary)
2. Apply roofing cement to exposed nail heads
3. Clear gutters to prevent water backup

Cost Comparison:

3. Granule Loss (Sign of Aging Shingles)

What It Looks Like

• Bald spots on shingles
• Granules in gutters

Main Causes

• Normal wear & tear (10+ year-old roofs)
• Hail or heavy rain damage
• Defective shingles

Risks of Ignoring It

• Reduced UV protection (faster deterioration)
• Higher energy bills (less heat reflection)

How to Fix Roof Shingle Damage

• Minor loss: Monitor & clean gutters.
• Severe loss: Consider asphalt roof replacement.

Action Plan by Severity:

Cost:

• Full replacement only (granules can’t be replaced).

4. Cracked Shingles (Often from Freeze-Thaw Cycles)

What It Looks Like

Visible splits or fractures in shingles.

Main Causes

• Temperature swings (common in New England)
• Foot traffic (walking on the roof)
• Brittle old shingles

How to Fix Roof Shingle Damage

• Small cracks: Seal with roofing cement.
• Large cracks: Replace shingles.

Critical Zones

• Roof edges (greatest temperature swings)
• South-facing slopes (UV degradation)

Repair Matrix:

Cost:

• Per shingle repair: $75–$200

Note: The shingle roof repair prices listed here are approximate—actual costs may vary depending on the contractor and the complexity of the issue.

5. Blistering Shingles (Trapped Moisture)

What It Looks Like

Small bubbles or raised spots on shingles.
Science Behind It

When shingles are manufactured, some moisture can get trapped inside. Under intense heat, this moisture turns to vapor and creates blisters or bubbles. Popping these blisters can damage the shingles and may void warranties, especially on premium products.

Main Causes

•  Poor ventilation (moisture gets trapped)
•  Manufacturing defects

How to Fix Roof Shingle Damage

• Puncture & seal small blisters (temporary fix).
• Replace severely blistered shingles.

Professional Repair:

1. Infrared scan to map moisture pockets
2. Targeted replacement of affected areas
3. Ventilation upgrades (1 sq ft vent/150 sq ft attic space)

Cost:

• Spot repair: $100-$300 [NOTE: This is an approximate cost, which depends on the issue severity and different roofing contractors].

6. Algae/Moss Growth (Common in Shaded Areas)

What It Looks Like

• Black streaks (algae)
• Green patches (moss)

Risks of Ignoring It

• retains moisture and affects roof rot.
• Shortens shingle lifespan

How to Fix Roof Shingle Damage

• Clean with a 50/50 bleach & water mix (gentle pressure wash).
• Install zinc or copper strips to prevent regrowth.

Removal Protocol

1. Soft wash (PSI <500) with Wet & Forget cleaner
2. Zinc strip installation along ridge ($4/linear foot)
3. Trim tree branches to reduce shade

Never:

• Use pressure washers (>800 PSI strips granules)
• Scrub with stiff brushes (damages surface)

Cost:

• Professional cleaning: $300–$600  [NOTE: This is an approximate cost, which depends on the issue severity and different roofing contractors].

7. Wind Damage (Lifted or Flapping Shingles)

What It Looks Like

• Shingles not lying flat
• Visible nail pops

Shingle Wind Ratings

Different types of shingles can handle different wind speeds. Check out this table to see how strong each type is against windy weather.

Post-Storm Checklist:

1. Inspect for tears at nail points
2. Check flashing around chimneys
3. Look for “zipper” patterns (sequential lifting)

How to Fix Roof Shingle Damage

• Re-nail loose shingles (apply sealant).
• Replace severely damaged ones.

Cost:

• Per shingle repair: $100–$250 [NOTE: This is an approximate cost, which depends on the issue severity and different roofing contractors].

When to DIY vs. Call a Roofing Contractor

2025 Cost Comparison Table of Roof Shingle Damage Repair

Prevention Tips to Extend Roof Shingle Damage Life

• Annual inspections (especially after storms)
• Keep gutters clean (prevents water backup)
• Trim overhanging branches (reduces moss & debris)
• Upgrade to architectural shingles (more durable)
• Ensure proper attic ventilation (reduces curling & blistering)

Conclusion

Roof shingle damage starts small but worsens quickly. Catching issues early saves thousands in repairs.

Need help?

• For minor repairs, use our tips.
• For major damage, trust a professional roofing contractor near you.

Call Our Roofing Experts Today!

Serving Falmouth, Mashpee & nearby areas since 1970
Call for free estimate: 508-775-8240
Check our Google reviews & book directly!